The pen is Scarier
than the sword
Join us for a
Story telling Experience
Grand Release
October 1st, 2025
Featured Products
Story Merch
These tiny gems are a beautiful trinket to take you right back to Crooked Forks, and the terrifying creatures that lives there.
*Picture for reference only
Available in Adult S - 3X. Show your love for scary stories with our Element of Mystery Hoodie!
Behind the Pen
Our family has always had a love for the spooky and mysterious. From my love of horror, whether a movie, book, or experience to my wife’s obsession with mysteries and puzzles we have spent years embracing the creepy and undiscovered. We are so excited to be bringing that passion to all of you through our stories. With over a dozen stories already written or in the works, we have so much to offer, are you brave enough to join us for the ride?
Keep the fear alive on social
Contact Us
Have questions for us at Element of Mystery? Have a good story you want us to include in our upcoming “Element of Truth” series based on our own and reader’s true stories? Simply want to say hi? Send us a message! We will personally respond to each of you!